The end of shareholder primacy and its impact on equity valuations

The COVID-19 pandemic is likely to accelerate this shift, requiring investors to understand the value companies have been creating for and extracting from all stakeholders.

clock • 1 min read

In brief:

  • In our view, society has started to shift away from the shareholder primacy model.
  • The COVID-19 pandemic is likely to accelerate this shift, requiring investors to understand the value companies have been creating for and extracting from all stakeholders.
  • We believe this shift suggests that margins could be lower versus expectations in coming years.

Despite its length, the recently ended eleven-year business cycle created meager economic growth relative to the generous returns that financial markets provided to investors. Central bankers expected low interest rates to spur corporate animal spirits, growth in capital expenditures and inflation aimed for the benefit of all. Instead, rather than creating wage growth and other broad societal benefits, the ballooning of central bank balance sheets unintentionally financed asset price inflation as dividends and share repurchases boomed.

This failing occurred alongside a peak in investor short-termism. Against a backdrop of below-average revenue growth early in the cycle to midcycle, corporations recognized the market's thirst for capital return amid slight regard for long-term value. Corporates gave the market what it wanted.

During the last business cycle, companies in the S&P 500 Index returned more than $9 trillion to shareholders, a sizable chunk of the index's $23 trillion market capitalization, mainly by leveraging their balance sheets. This helped push equity valuations higher in a way that was grossly inconsistent with the pace of US or global economic growth. The shareholder primacy model — the idea that corporations exist primarily to serve the interests of shareholders — was on full display.

Advertisement

More on Investment

Partner Insight: PIMCO Outlook - The fragmentation era

Partner Insight: PIMCO Outlook - The fragmentation era

With the world order in flux, investors can look to fortify portfolios by diversifying across global markets and capitalising on attractive, high-quality yields.

Richard Clarida, Andrew Balls and Daniel Ivascyn at PIMCO
clock 09 July 2025 • 10 min read
Now Pensions makes first private markets investment

Now Pensions makes first private markets investment

Supports ambition to invest at least 10% of its default fund in private market assets

Holly Roach
clock 07 July 2025 • 1 min read
Partner Insight: Managing investment risks in retirement

Partner Insight: Managing investment risks in retirement

The need to manage investment risks in retirement is more acute now than ever before. Recent stock market volatility and upside inflation risks from tariffs are once again focusing minds on the phenomenon known as sequencing risk.

Trevor Greetham, Head of Multi Asset at Royal London Asset Management
clock 07 July 2025 • 2 min read
Trustpilot