Comment: Avoiding past mistakes

clock

Ask any asset management expert how they will remember the past decade, and the answers will be unsurprisingly grim. I heard about the end of the defined benefit plan, the swift unwinding of retirement security and the "lost decade".

 

Fidelity’s Mark Miller said to me, “Fifty to 60 years of retirement provision was unwound in the space of a decade”. 

But the last ten years provided some valuable lessons, particularly around risk management. As Global Pensions reports this month, one of the most drastic changes we’ll see in pension funds’ behaviour over the next ten years will be an increased understanding of risk, an understanding that will be embedded in portfolio creation and asset allocation decisions. Click here to view article

How long can this last? An optimist would argue there has been a permanent change in the way investors chase returns; that the lure of the outsized and esoteric has faded. There are already signs of this happening. Pension funds are getting back to basics and funnelling their investments in assets they understand. 

In reality, though, I come back to a comment by BNY Mellon Asset Management’s vice chairman Jonathan Little, who simply said, “People have short term memories. Each crisis that occurs is different, but it’s not that different.” He said the lesson only lasts until the guy who remembers the last crisis retires. 

We’ve all heard the refrain, “Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me”. I hope decades down the road, investors won’t be playing the fool. 

 

Raquel Pichardo-Allison, Deputy Editor

 

More on Investment

Partner Insight: Can stewardship shape real world outcomes for pension funds?

Partner Insight: Can stewardship shape real world outcomes for pension funds?

Stewardship has moved well beyond voting statistics. For pension investors, it is now about whether engagement is shaping real-world outcomes across climate, people, governance and systems-level risks.

Royal London Asset Management
clock 29 July 2026 • 5 min read
UK pension giants join forces to unlock £1bn for scale-up fund

UK pension giants join forces to unlock £1bn for scale-up fund

Scale-up fund will help boost investment in science and technology businesses

Jonathan Stapleton
clock 27 July 2026 • 4 min read
Schroders refocuses UK institutional team amid partnership approach push

Schroders refocuses UK institutional team amid partnership approach push

Asset manager prepares for a future of fewer, but far larger, pots of pension capital

Jonathan Stapleton
clock 27 July 2026 • 5 min read
Trustpilot